修辭同學詢問:Salt deposits and moisture threaten to destroy the Mohenjo-Daro excavation in Pakistan, the site of an ancient civilization that
------
flourished at the same time as the civilizations in the Nile delta and
--------------------------------------------------------------
the river valleys of Tigris and Euphrates.
老師 這題是題本的第115題,這是正確答案我沒有問題,問題是你在上課有提到可以補出動詞在畫線最後變成 civilizations "did",也是對的....但是...後來你下堂課又說到另一個句子 "People in Taiwan consume more than twice as much paper per people as they "did" ten years ago. 裡面的did是錯的,應該改成consumed. 我有點困惑=_=
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
康康老師:did 的先行詞是誰… 是consume
不對,它是現在式,怎會是DID過去式的先行詞。懂了嗎!
文章標籤
全站熱搜

這回答真的是康康老師留的嗎? 解釋的思路很匪夷所思...... 原句留個 did 是正確的。 "People...consume...paper (now)" 比上 "people consumed paper ten years ago",寫在後半的子句可以使用替代詞合理精簡,所以對應位置上的 people 以 they 替代,consumed 以助動詞 did 替代。
同學您好:這個部份確實是康老師於FB上留言的文章轉PO的 (可看FB的資訊:https://goo.gl/qqkwBY ),已協助將您的問題放至FB上,待康老師回覆後,會再回覆給您,謝謝! ------------------------------------------------------ 康老師回覆如下:People in Taiwan consume more than twice as much paper per people as they "did" ten years ago. 這句中did前,並沒consumed這個過去式,可以代,所以did是錯的。 (原文於FB的資訊:https://goo.gl/qqkwBY ) 若還有任何的疑問,歡迎再提出,或是上FB私訊康老師確認喔 ^^ 字神助教 於 2016/05/01